Four roommates are thinking about hiring a $100 / week cleaning service.  The roommates value this weekly service differently as follows:

• Josh values it at $20 
• Joaquim values it at $40
• X Æ A-12 values it at $30
• Apple values it as $20

Once the good (a clean apartment) is provided, there is no way to prevent one roommate from benefing (non-excludable) and the fact that it is clean for one person does not diminish it for others (non-rival) .

Based on this on this set-up, discuss the following questions:

Should it by provided? What is your criteria?

Will it by provided? (There is no one correct answer here… just think through different scenarios)